The news, with a bit of spin

Vacherot is Shanghai champion but “not defending”: Maxime looks for the nuance

Monaco’s Valentin Vacherot, last year’s winner in Shanghai, beat Argentina’s Sebastian Baez 6-4, 7-6 in the first round on centre court. He said he was not approaching the tournament as a title defence.

Maxime, an intern journalist, puzzles on a train over a notebook flowchart with a trophy and a crossed-out shield, a tennis court behind.

Silly question, but if you won a tournament last year and you come back to it, what do you do, exactly?

Valentin Vacherot, from Monaco, the defending champion, beat Argentina’s Sebastian Baez 6-4, 7-6 in his opening match at the Shanghai Masters 1000. On centre court. So far, I’m following. Then he said in his press conference: “I tried not to think of it as a title defence.”

I wrote that in my notebook, on the 7:32 train, and I worked it through. Step one: he has the title. Step two: he is not defending it. Step three: so if somebody else wins it, he hasn’t lost it, since he wasn’t defending it. Step four: so he can be the defending champion forever without ever defending anything. I thought the system was brilliant. Then I reread it, and I have a doubt about step three.

He also said: “It would be too arrogant to say I’m only here to defend my title.” Only. The word matters. So he defends a bit, but not only. I tried to work out the percentage. My notebook doesn’t go that far.

What he does instead is be happy. He said the joy of being back in Shanghai outweighed everything else. He even said he didn’t really know whether he would get to play this first round on centre court. The defending champion, unsure he gets the main court. I’m told it’s tour politeness, fine, but what does that mean?

I asked Jean-Pol if he had ever defended a title.

Several times. With arrogance. That’s how you keep them, you know.

Jean-Pol Vandenbroeck · the pundit, fictional character

He couldn’t tell me which ones. I looked, I found nothing, and I stopped looking when he looked at me.

Anyway, I still have a lot to learn.

It’s true, we checked: We Love Tennis.

Did you enjoy this dispatch?

Get the dispatches by e-mail

The dispatches worth your time, by e-mail. No ads, unsubscribe in one click.

Also the mail from our other titles:

Our columnists’ reactions are fictional; the facts and real quotes are sourced above.

The other angle in French

The editor-in-chief chose this one: « B applique le déroulé logique jusqu'à l'absurde avec une voix candide impeccable, et le joueur peut le partager sans arrière-pensée. A est plus piquant que drôle, C trébuche sur la santé, D sur une scène inventée. »

Vacherot ne veut pas « défendre » son titre à Shanghai : Jean-Pol, lui, défend le sien

Tenant du titre, le Monégasque Valentin Vacherot a battu l'Argentin Sebastian Baez 6-4, 7-6 pour son entrée en lice au Masters 1000 de Shanghai, sur le court central. En conférence de presse, il a expliqué ne pas considérer cette édition comme une défense de titre.

  • Funniness 3/5
  • Faithfulness 4/5
  • Voice 4/5
  • Retweet 3/5
  • Good nature 4/5

The editor-in-chief’s comment Le titre défendu « moralement » et la photo de la buvette font sourire, mais « il pourrait l'assumer » et « défend tout » sonnent comme un reproche au joueur.

Read this angle →